God’s Apple Tree: Did God Plan the Fall?

“The Lord God took the human and settled him in the garden of Eden to farm it and to take care of it.  The Lord God commanded the human, ‘Eat your fill from all of the garden’s trees; but don’t eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, because on the day you eat from it, you will die!  Then the Lord God said, “It’s not good that the human is alone.  I will make him a helper that is perfect for him.  So the Lord God formed from the fertile land all the wild animals and all the birds in the sky and brought them to the human to see what he would name them.  The human gave each living being its name…[b]ut a helper perfect for him was nowhere to be found.  So the Lord God put the human into a deep and heavy sleep…the Lord God fashioned a woman and brought her to the human being….

The snake was the most intelligent of all the wild animals that the Lord God had made.  He said to the woman, ‘Did God really say that you shouldn’t eat from any tree in the garden?'”   The woman said to the snake, ‘We may eat the fruit of the garden’s trees but not the fruit of the tree in the middle of the garden.  God said, ‘Don’t eat from it, and don’t touch it, or you will die.’  The snake said to the woman, ‘You won’t die!  God knows that on the day you eat from it, you will see clearly and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.  The woman saw that the tree was beautiful with delicious food and that the tree would provide wisdom, so she took some of its fruit and ate it, and also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it.  Then they both saw clearly and knew that they were naked.  (selected verses from Genesis 2:15-22, 3:1-7, CEB)

A few observations:
1) God created the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, either in actual physical form or as a symbolic expression of a spiritual reality.

2) God told the human to not eat of it before the partner, woman, was formed.

3) The story does not say who tells the woman this information.

4) The story includes that the “snake was the most intelligent of all the wild animals that the Lord God had made”.  Three points on this:  a) God created the snake, b) God made it intelligent, but not as intelligent as humans (‘wild animals’), and c) how did the snake know about the tree?

Theological Questions Based on these Observations
1) Why did God create the tree of knowledge of good and evil?

2) Does the tree of knowledge of good and evil represent a concept or knowledge of actual “good” and “evil” beings?  (Up to this point in Genesis  it is my understanding that God saw all His creation as good.)

3) Why/how did the snake (as created by God to be the most intelligent of the wild animals) have any interest in deceiving the humans?

4) Should we assume that up to this point that God has full domain over all actions/thoughts/causes/effects within creation?  Is Free Will only after the Fall?

Where am I going with this?
It is in my God-given nature to question and test, discerning what is of God and what is not.  I do not bring this up to dispute other interpretations, but rather offer the question up for discussion – as we are all reflections of God, our combined discernment is more helpful then me sitting in a room by myself (or with my little kids).

If God planned the Fall, then the details of our theological assumptions come into question:

1) Did God use the woman in a similar way of using Judas to fulfill God’s Plan?  If so, how does this change the Christian conception of women?

2) For that matter, is the snake involved in this event at the direction of God?

3) Does the knowledge and existence of evil need to be embraced differently if it is something God intended and created?  (Please note here that I use ‘knowledge’ not ‘enacted’, just as in the scriptures.)

What do you think?  I am eagerly awaiting your thoughts!

Only a few short weeks before the Finding Purpose and Balance Spiritual Retreat in Excelsior, MN!  This is a wonderful opportunity to benefit from Jasna Burza’s amazing insights and enjoy a mental/spiritual spa day!

About SFriant

I live to walk with others on their journeys - because everyone needs to know that they are loved, that they matter, and that they are doing amazing things. I'm a lot like our two kids: obsessed with learning, and constantly creating.
This entry was posted in Theology and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to God’s Apple Tree: Did God Plan the Fall?

  1. dunnpenquite says:

    Interesting questions! This is a story I’ve always had trouble with. If I believe in a Parent God, I find it hard to believe God would set up such a temptation just for temptation’s sake. Any good parent knows you don’t put something interesting out within reach of the child and say “It’s really cool, but you can’t touch it!” And then get mad when they do. It seems almost abusive to me to put a child in a situation where you know they’ll have a very hard time controlling themselves and then punish them for doing what is in their nature. So, I cant believe a loving Parent God would do that either.
    But, you know I’m not a literalist when it comes to Biblical stories, so I’m sure my opinion isn’t a surprise 🙂

    • SFriant says:

      If the story is literal or spiritual truth, your observations carry the same weight. Did “we” sin by not listening to God, or was this part of the human journey? While as parents we try to not purposely tempt our children towards something we would be angry at, there are times when children – and we as parents – need to learn by doing.

  2. Pingback: Pro-Love Letter: Two Trees | In Phase News

  3. Pingback: Pro-Love Letter: Universal Salvation | In Phase News

  4. SFriant says:

    Romans 8:20-21 (CEB) Creation was subjected to frustration, not by its own choice-it was the choice of the one who subjected it-but in the hope that the creation itself will be set free from slavery to decay and brought into the glorious freedom of God’s children.

Comments are closed.